03-16-2010, 05:06 PM
good grief, don't be so thin skinned. I was joking about Bb. jeepers (also composing in Bb is good if you're printing out your music for reeds, you just shift to concert c when you print)
also if you can honestly tell the difference between a 320kbps mp3 and a lossless WAV, great, but I can't tell the difference and honestly nobody i've met can either. I'll be over here enjoying tiny files. And if you feel lossless is ABSOLUTELY necessary, use FLAC and enjoy 50% smaller files with the exact same waveform.
As to sounding cruel, sorry. I come across as that but i'm not trying to be mean or discourage you from composing at all. These are just my honest thoughts on the pieces you posted. Frankly I think a little bit of harsh feedback will improve your compositions a lot more than 20 "hey gj man;)"s will do.
also if you can honestly tell the difference between a 320kbps mp3 and a lossless WAV, great, but I can't tell the difference and honestly nobody i've met can either. I'll be over here enjoying tiny files. And if you feel lossless is ABSOLUTELY necessary, use FLAC and enjoy 50% smaller files with the exact same waveform.
As to sounding cruel, sorry. I come across as that but i'm not trying to be mean or discourage you from composing at all. These are just my honest thoughts on the pieces you posted. Frankly I think a little bit of harsh feedback will improve your compositions a lot more than 20 "hey gj man;)"s will do.