Posts: 550
Threads: 62
Joined: May 2009
Which kind of battle system do you enjoy the most?
its a pretty easy question but i would like to find out what is more popular, the option is between Action Battle Systems and Side View Battle System?
I Prefer Action Battle Systems (Abs) and my favorite which i am using for my game since on the website he said that it can be used for commercial games as well as non-commercial games.
Posts: 1,664
Threads: 391
Joined: May 2009
I'm more of an action kind of guy... and I don't like waiting, so I pick ABS. :P
Posts: 550
Threads: 62
Joined: May 2009
Me too but i don't see many Rpg games around that are Abs so i began to wonder what developers are doing.
Posts: 11,230
Threads: 649
Joined: May 2009
Well, ABS systems are almost rewrites of the entire Scene_Battle system and add-ons for them are comparably few and far between. And there is no standard so an actual add-on for one ABS system may not work on another ABS system. That, and most allow for just single-player controls. Some don't handle party AI that well.
Meanwhile, a sideview battlesystem is really (more or less) a graphic rewrite system, making your frontview battlesystem LOOK sideview. Some may be more in-depth and have actual battlesystem code that rewrites Scene_Battle. But since the actual battlesystem itself is based on Scene_Battle, there is a larger variety of add-ons you can use with your battlesystem.
*shrugs*
Working with an ABS system by Mr.Mo right now. It's the only one I know that works with the NetPlay 2.0
Online Play system.
Trying to make it hack n slash more like Diablo.
Even so, a good sideview system allows you to control a good sized party. And who can pass up leading a small army against a hoard of demons and orcs? Especially if a well crafted visual tour-de-force? Gotta go sideview here.
Posts: 550
Threads: 62
Joined: May 2009
Well it seems that everyone loves easy to make stuff.
anyway the first part of what you said was really irrelevant because we are talking about game play and how much you enjoy it.
i take it that you are not the action type like Punk.
Posts: 80
Threads: 9
Joined: May 2009
I have to say sideview since it's is extremly easy to add charsets especially if you using Paradog SVBS since there's no need to use a battlers for party members at all. since the charsets act as the battlers. Also it's even more fun if you can gen 4 party members plus support to actually help the party members.
Posts: 550
Threads: 62
Joined: May 2009
Yeah my topic is alive again!
still i think ABS are the best as witht action you can hardly show that to gamers.
Posts: 299
Threads: 9
Joined: May 2009
I absolutely HATE ABS systems in 2 dimensional four-direction games. It just doesn't work, at all. I can't stand playing them. Yes, every game I made used to use them, but then I wasn't actually playing the game so I didn't notice how absolutely god-awful and gameplayless it made it. I've never seen a 2d 4-dir ABS done well.
Personally I prefer sideview in a 2D game - Final Fantasy esque if you like. But with at least something imaginative added.
Posts: 550
Threads: 62
Joined: May 2009
you only say that because of square enix!
sit down and think about it, the games that you played were probably garbage to begin with!
also the developers are so half assed that they fall short on th story because of the functionality of the abs, while side view are simple which allow the half assed developer to focus more on story than actual game play.
Posts: 84
Threads: 5
Joined: May 2009
Wyatt Wrote:I absolutely HATE ABS systems in 2 dimensional four-direction games. It just doesn't work, at all. I can't stand playing them. Yes, every game I made used to use them, but then I wasn't actually playing the game so I didn't notice how absolutely god-awful and gameplayless it made it. I've never seen a 2d 4-dir ABS done well.
Personally I prefer sideview in a 2D game - Final Fantasy esque if you like. But with at least something imaginative added.
I agree with this! Well, I enjoyed playing Zeldas in 2D, but ABS systems on RPG Maker are just awful in my opinion. And I really mean it, when I see a project on RPG Maker and I read "ABS", I don't want to download it at all.
Which kind of battle system do you enjoy the most?
